Years after controversial marriage, Falls City couple at risk of losing children

Matthew and Crystal Koso

Crystal Koso and her husband, Matthew Koso, share a teary goodbye in this February 2006 file photo. Matthew Koso had just been sentenced to 18 to 30 months for first-degree sexual assault of Crystal, who was 14 when he impregnated her. (Journal Star file photo)

Journal Star file photo

Prefer us on Google Learn More

By JoANNE YOUNG / Lincoln Journal Star

They showed up Wednesday at the Richardson County courthouse.

A 21-year-old mother of four; her husband, 29, the father of three of the children; and a 24-year-old man in handcuffs, leg restraints and prison-issued clothing, the father of one of the four children.

They listened as Judge Curtis Maschman told them Christopher Halbert, attorney for the children, was seeking to end their rights to be parents.

They said they understood and had no questions.

But Crystal Koso, the mother, Matthew Koso and Dominic Pagnano Jr., the fathers, denied the allegations in the petition. Matthew Koso was assigned his own attorney, and he and his wife were provided guardian-ad-litem attorneys to look after each of their best interests.

It's a new chapter in the story of the girl who got pregnant and married young, and the man who served 15 months in prison for having sex with her from the time she was 12. They married in Kansas, where it's legal, when she was 14. He was 22. 

People are also reading…

Their story made headlines in their home state, across the country and beyond.

Newly wed, they settled amid the ruckus in Falls City. In the next seven years, Crystal Koso gave birth to four children.

And things got even messier -- too messy for anyone to continue to describe the story as young love that overcomes all odds.

Nine months into the marriage, Matthew Koso went to prison for 15 months, from February 2006 to May 2007. During that time, Crystal got pregnant. The child fathered by Dominic "D.J." Pagnano was born in October 2007.

But Matthew Koso came back and stuck around. They had two more babies, in 2009 and 2010.

And their story continued in newspapers and on talk shows and Internet forums, where anonymous writers judged the most famous, or infamous, couple in Falls City. 

"What an embarrassment. SHEEEEESH!" was one of the more indulgent Internet comments from a Falls City resident.

The petition seeking to terminate their parental rights alleges Matthew has neglected his children, failing to give them the care and protection necessary for their health, education and morals. He is unfit as a parent, due to debauchery, use of alcohol or drugs, or repeated lewd and lascivious behavior, it says.

The petition accuses him of subjecting the kids to more severe abuses, including the possibility of sexual abuse.

The mother, the petition alleges, also neglected her kids and is unfit.

And, it alleges that Pagnano, who has been in prison since April 2010 for two counts of sexual assault on a child and possession of child pornography, neglected and abandoned his child. 

Listen now and subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | RSS Feed | SoundStack | All Of Our Podcasts

The children were removed Oct. 4, 2010. They were returned about two weeks later for about a month, then taken again when the parents flew to the East Coast to tape the Steve Wilkos Show, the couple said.

They believe the state, case workers and the kids' attorney have it all wrong.

The Kosos say the removals started because someone called authorities and reported they had a dirty house. They don't know who made the report, they said last week.

The police or case workers would come to the house in between cleaning times, they said. Like right after lunch when the baby had knocked a jar of food on the floor. Or when the kids had just smeared food from their Easy Bake oven around the room.

Three of the children are in Lincoln in foster homes and one is in Dawson with grandparents. They visit their parents, with supervision, one day a week for about three hours. The continuation of those visits will be addressed at a hearing this week.

There have been accusations, including sexual abuse allegations, made against them, the Kosos said, that are just not true.

For example, the petition says they are financially able to take care of the kids, but neither has a job, Crystal Koso said.

Her husband said he gets a military pension from an injury he got while in the Marines after serving four months.

They have completed required parenting classes in Omaha, they said. They go to therapy in Beatrice.

Workers tell them they have to be more positive, and Matthew needs to work on his anger, Crystal said.

"If Matt had a reason not to be angry, I think that would be appropriate," she said. "But people keep coming into our house saying we have to fix this, this, this and this."

They don't have the money to spend on the many items the state demands for the house, such as a programmable thermostat, air filters, a fire extinguisher in the kitchen, Matt said.

Crystal Koso said their house is clean, and they've done everything they can to comply with the requirements of the state.

It's been hard, Matt said, because he hasn't been able to find a job, other than temporary ones at grain elevators. They've relied on family for support.

The Kosos want their children back.

"We want the kids to come home, but we're not totally sure that that's what we're gonna get," Matt Koso said.

Terminating their rights would be a crushing blow, he said.

"I've worked really hard since I got out of prison to help make my family and provide for them," he said.

Reach JoAnne Young at 402-473-7228 or jyoung@journalstar.com -- You can follow JoAnne's tweets at twitter.com/ljslegislature.

Close

Matthew and Crystal Koso

Crystal Koso and her husband, Matthew Koso, share a teary goodbye in this February 2006 file photo. Matthew Koso had just been sentenced to 18 to 30 months for first-degree sexual assault of Crystal, who was 14 when he impregnated her. (Journal Star file photo)